The content on this page has been converted from PDF to HTML format using an artificial intelligence (AI) tool as part of our ongoing efforts to improve accessibility and usability of our publications. Note:
- No human verification has been conducted of the converted content.
- While we strive for accuracy errors or omissions may exist.
- This content is provided for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as a definitive or authoritative source.
- For the official and verified version of the publication, refer to the original PDF document.
If you identify any inaccuracies or have concerns about the content, please contact us at [email protected].
Ethics and Technology: Ethical considerations relating to the provision of insights obtained through the use of technology to an audited entity
The FRC does not accept any liability to any party for any loss, damage or costs howsoever arising, whether directly or indirectly, whether in contract, tort or otherwise from any action or decision taken (or not taken) as a result of any person relying on or otherwise using this document or arising from any omission from it.
The Financial Reporting Council Limited 2026
The Financial Reporting Council Limited is a company limited by guarantee. Registered in England number 2486368. Registered Office: 13th Floor, 1 Harbour Exchange Square, London, E14 9GE
- Introduction
- 1. Is communication of the insight required by the auditing standards?
- 2. Would communication of the insight constitute providing a non-audit service or a favour?
- 3. Would communication of the insight pose a threat to integrity, objectivity or independence?
- 4. Ethical considerations in relation to providing an audited entity with access to technology that enables it to derive insights
- 5. Illustrative examples
Introduction
In the course of an audit, the auditor may obtain a wide variety of insights about the entity or its environment, often through the use of technology. The growing prevalence of artificial intelligence (AI) in audit may lead to an increase in the quantity of these insights for two reasons. Firstly, AI can itself facilitate the performance of new forms of procedure that can generate insights. Secondly, AI can act as a catalyst for audit firms to explore and use more traditional forms of technology in audit to a greater extent, including data analytics.
Reporting these insights to those charged with governance or management of the audited entity can create threats to integrity, objectivity or independence in some circumstances, especially where the work performed to obtain the insight does not form part of the audit of financial statements. The purpose of an audit is to enhance the confidence of the intended users in the financial statements, and achieving this is the principal way that an audit serves the public interest. The auditor should not provide insights that would undermine this objective, for example by compromising the actual or perceived integrity, objectivity or independence of the auditor.
We expect an increase in technology-derived insights and the provision of these insights can pose distinct threats. We therefore see value in publishing guidance on how to apply relevant ethical requirements in relation to the provision of insights obtained through the use of technology. We intend this guidance to:
- Reduce the risk that auditors provide insights obtained through the use of technology that compromise their integrity, objectivity or independence and ability to discharge their responsibilities as statutory auditor; and
- Provide confidence to auditors in relation to how to apply the relevant ethical requirements and therefore support the provision of insights obtained through the use of technology that do not compromise integrity, objectivity or independence. This is in recognition of the fact that, in many cases, for example in relation to control deficiencies or identified risks of material misstatements, the provision of these insights may serve the public interest through enhancing the quality of internal control, corporate reporting and audit.
This guidance discusses the communication of insights obtained through the use of technology to management or those charged with governance, and the provision of access to technology that enables them to obtain insights directly.
For the purposes of this guidance, insights may be observations, analyses, recommendations or conclusions specific to an audited entity or its environment that may enhance the recipient's understanding. Insights communicated in general thought leadership pieces are outside the scope of this guidance.
Section 1 acknowledges that some communication is required by the auditing standards, and that such communication does not require further consideration from an ethics and independence perspective. Communication not required by auditing standards is considered in sections 2 and 3. Section 2 discusses whether it constitutes providing a non-audit service or a favour, while section 3 discusses when it may pose threats to integrity, objectivity or independence. Section 4 recognises that similar considerations may arise if the auditor provides audited entity personnel with access to technology that enables them to derive insights, focusing on what is new or different in that context. Section 5 contains two illustrative examples.
This guidance is non-authoritative. It explains how the existing ethical and independence requirements may be understood and applied. It does not set any additional requirements.
It is not expected that the auditor will formally consider or document against the content of this guidance in relation to every communication of an insight obtained through the use of technology to management or those charged with governance. This guidance may help develop auditors' awareness of potential threats to their integrity, objectivity or independence and their ability to recognise circumstances in which more detailed consideration may be appropriate. In particular, and as discussed in section 3, formal consideration of the guidance may often be not required in relation to insights derived from work performed to support the audit opinion, or to fulfil the auditor's responsibilities under the auditing standards.
The principles and considerations discussed in this guidance may be relevant in relation to insights not obtained through the use of technology. Professional judgement should be exercised in applying them in that context.
1. Is communication of the insight required by the auditing standards?
ISAs (UK) require communication of certain information to management and/or those charged with governance. This includes communication specifically mentioned as required under the ISAs (UK), as well as communication that the auditor reasonably judges supports the fulfilment of their responsibilities under ISAs (UK).
ISAs (UK) 260 and 265 contain communication related requirements that are perhaps most relevant to the communication of insights obtained through the use of technology.1 2 These require the communication of significant findings from the audit and deficiencies in internal control to those charged with governance, and communication of significant deficiencies in internal control, and other identified deficiencies that merit management's attention, to appropriate management.
| Significant finding example | Significant internal control deficiency example |
|---|---|
| In auditing the bad debt provision, the auditor uses data analytics to compare contractual due dates and subsequent receipts across the customer population. This reveals that customers meeting certain criteria are taking progressively longer to pay. The auditor knows that these customers account for an increasing proportion of sales and judges that there are implications for management's provisioning assumptions, although the current-year provision is not materially misstated. They communicate the finding to those charged with governance. | In testing purchase controls, the auditor uses a machine learning algorithm to identify clusters of purchases that may relate to the same project despite spanning different suppliers, dates and cost centres. Although individual orders were approved, the total project expenditure did not receive the higher-level approval required by the entity's policy, as the purchasing process does not effectively bring related commitments together for approval. The auditor determines that this is a significant control deficiency and communicates it, together with analysis showing the extent of expenditure affected, to those charged with governance and appropriate management. |
Other auditing standards require communication that may include insights obtained through the use of technology, including, but not limited to:
- Communication of identified or suspected fraud to appropriate management and, in specified circumstances, those charged with governance, and of other fraud-related matters that the auditor judges relevant to the responsibilities of those charged with governance, unless prohibited by law or regulation;3
- Communication of identified or suspected non-compliance with laws and regulations to appropriate management and, where applicable, those charged with governance, unless prohibited by law or regulation;4
- Communication of accumulated misstatements to appropriate management, and uncorrected misstatements and their potential effect on the audit opinion to those charged with governance, unless prohibited by law or regulation;5
- Communication of significant matters arising during the audit in connection with the entity's related parties to those charged with governance;6
- Communication of identified events or conditions that may cast significant doubt on the entity's ability to continue as a going concern to those charged with governance.7
Required communication, as well as communication that the auditor reasonably judges supports the fulfilment of their responsibilities under the ISAs (UK), is not a non-audit service and does not pose a threat to integrity, objectivity or independence.
2. Would communication of the insight constitute providing a non-audit service or a favour?
It is a matter of professional judgement whether the communication of an insight obtained through the use of technology, and the work performed to obtain it, would constitute a non-audit service or a favour. If the communication is part of the audit see section 2.1.1 Would the communication be part of the audit? – then communication does not constitute providing a non-audit service or a favour.
The FRC Ethical Standard discusses, but does not define, favours. The communication of an insight that is not part of the audit may be perceived to be a favour, if market fees for that insight are not charged.
2.1 Would communication of the insight constitute providing a non-audit service?
The Ethical Standard defines a non-audit service as any engagement in which an audit firm provides professional services to an audited entity or its affiliates, other than the audit of financial statements of the audited entity.8
To judge whether the communication of an insight would constitute providing a non-audit service, the auditor may apply a two-part test: (i) would the communication be part of the audit and (ii) would it constitute providing an engagement. If the communication would not be part of the audit, and would constitute providing an engagement, it would constitute providing a non-audit service.
2.1.1 Would the communication be part of the audit?
The communication of an insight is part of the audit if:
- The objective of the work performed to obtain the insight is to gather evidence to support the firm's opinion on the financial statements, and
- The nature and extent of any testing performed to obtain the insight is determined by the firm, or in the case of a group, the work of other firms in relation to group components, in the context of expressing an opinion on the financial statements, and
- The principal terms and conditions for the work performed to obtain the insight are the same as those of the audit.9
The first of these criteria does not require that the work is performed to directly gather evidence. Work that indirectly supports this objective, for example, setting materiality or considering other information in accordance with the requirements of ISA (UK) 720, and indeed any work that is performed to meet the requirements of auditing standards, is part of the audit too. The communication of insights obtained through the performance of this work may be construed as part of the audit.
Determining whether or not work is performed in support of the audit opinion, or to meet responsibilities under the auditing standards, requires consideration of the rationale for performing the work, and is not affected by whether the work is ultimately relevant to the formation of the opinion.
It may be that a portion of the work to obtain the insight is performed in support of the audit opinion or to meet the requirements of auditing standards, and a portion is not performed for that purpose. The latter portion is not part of the audit and communicating an insight derived from that work may constitute providing a non-audit service.
2.1.2 Would communication constitute providing an engagement?
The term engagement in the non-audit service definition is itself not defined, but it may be understood to refer to a service provided under a formal or tacit agreement.
The presence of an engagement letter or fee may provide clear evidence of agreement to provide that service, but their absence does not necessarily mean that an engagement does not exist. If management or those charged with governance request certain insights to be communicated, or if the firm states during the tender process that it will or may provide them, this may constitute tacit agreement to provide a service.
If the auditor performs work and consequently communicates an insight entirely of their own initiative, without prior formal or tacit agreement or discussion with management or those charged with governance, it is unlikely to be judged to constitute providing an engagement but it may nevertheless pose threats to integrity, objectivity or independence – see section 3.
2.2 Implications of each relevant permutation
| Permutation | Ethical implications |
|---|---|
| Communication would be part of the audit |
|
| Communication would not be part of the audit but would not constitute providing an engagement |
|
| Communication would not be part of the audit and would constitute providing an engagement |
|
3. Would communication of the insight pose a threat to integrity, objectivity or independence?
The Ethical Standard discusses a variety of threats to integrity, objectivity or independence, four of which are discussed in this section as potentially particularly relevant to the communication of insights.
The Ethical Standard casts some of these threats solely in the context of the provision of non-audit services, in particular the management and self-review threats.12 This guidance recognises that versions of these threats may also arise outside the context of a non-audit service engagement. For example, technology may enable near-continuous monitoring of an entity's controls, performed for the purposes of the audit, but if the auditor communicates every deficiency they identify in real time, then there is a risk that management rely on this auditor communication as part of their control environment, giving rise to a potential management threat.
Notwithstanding that, the performance of work to support the audit opinion, or to fulfil the auditor's responsibilities under the auditing standards, does not itself give rise to threats to integrity, objectivity or independence, and there is an expectation that there is a very low chance of a threat arising in relation to the communication of an insight derived from work performed in this context. Accordingly, it may not be necessary to formally consider or document threats to integrity, objectivity or independence in relation to such communication.
The perspective of an ORITP is central to any assessment of the presence and significance of threats to integrity, objectivity or independence.13 Where there is a threat, it is a matter of professional judgement whether safeguards are available that could eliminate the threat or reduce it to a level where integrity, objectivity and independence are not compromised.
3.1 Management threat
If it is probable that an ORITP would conclude that the communication, which may or may not be a non-audit service, would constitute playing the role of management, or playing any part in management decision making, then it is prohibited, as the resulting threat to independence is so great that it cannot be safeguarded.14
In judging whether the communication of an insight constitutes playing the role of management, consideration of whether it may be perceived as the auditor designing, implementing and maintaining an internal control of the audited entity may be particularly relevant.15
In judging whether the communication of an insight that is relevant to a management decision constitutes playing a part in management decision making, the ORITP may consider whether management will have regard to the insight when making the decision and, if so:
- The significance of the insight to the decision; and
- Whether management have the willingness and ability to critically evaluate the insight and retain genuine responsibility for and ownership of the decision.
Certain factors that may be relevant to the professional judgement as to whether the communication would constitute playing the role of management or any part in management decision making, are discussed in the table below. These factors are considerations in a holistic professional judgement; the presence of circumstances that may heighten the threat does not automatically mean that an ORITP would conclude that the auditor is playing the role of management or a part in management decision making.
| Factor | Explanation |
|---|---|
Information available to management Resources available to management |
If management lack the relevant expertise, information or resources to critically evaluate an insight, but nevertheless act upon it, an ORITP may conclude that the auditor in substance played a management role or a part in management decision making. Certain features of circumstances in which insights obtained through the use of technology are communicated may be particularly relevant when considering these factors, as compared to other insights, and may heighten the threat. Firstly, if the technology used is opaque, management may not be able to obtain an understanding of how the insight was obtained, and it may therefore be more challenging for them to critically evaluate the insight. Secondly, technology may enable a significantly higher volume of insights to be communicated than may have previously been possible. This may increase the risk that management act upon an insight without critically evaluating it. Thirdly, where management lack access to technology with capabilities similar to that used in obtaining the insight, there may be a heightened risk that management are not able to form an independent view to evaluate the insight against. In some cases, this may undermine their ability to critically evaluate the insight. None of these automatically mean that an ORITP would conclude that the auditor is playing a management role or a part in management decision making, but they may be relevant considerations. |
| Frequency of communication of insights | Technology may facilitate the provision of a higher volume of insights. If these insights are regularly acted upon then, in addition to the risk mentioned above relating to the volume of insights, consideration may be given to whether an ORITP may conclude that management rely on insights provided by the auditor and, if so, whether they may conclude that the auditor is playing the role of management or a part in management decision making. Threats should not solely be considered at the level of individual insights; threats may emerge due to the cumulative effect of the communication of a number of insights. |
| Culture and track record of management | The culture and track record of management with respect to the weight they put on input from the auditor, and their willingness to critically evaluate information and take responsibility for decisions may be relevant to a management threat assessment. |
| Risk of automation bias | Where the insight has been obtained through the use of technology, there may be a heightened management threat if management have previously displayed automation bias or if the insight is accompanied by claims about the reliability of the relevant technology. This is because an ORITP may be more likely to conclude that management have a biased view of the level of confidence that it is appropriate to have in the insight, such that they may act upon it without critical evaluation. |
| The scope of the insight | Communicating an insight that addresses a substantial proportion of the considerations relevant to the decision may be more likely to be perceived as playing a part in management decision making than a narrow observation. Where management have regard to such an insight, and management do not appropriately critically evaluate the insight, an ORITP may perceive the auditor as playing a substantial part in making the decision. |
| The importance of the insight to the management decision | An insight concerning a central or potentially decisive consideration may carry a higher management threat than one concerning a peripheral matter. If the insight may substantially resolve the choice between alternatives, then an ORITP may judge that the auditor played a substantial part in the decision, if management do not appropriately critically evaluate the insight. |
| Whether the communication of the insight was requested by management, and if so how | Management requesting the insight, as opposed to the auditor communicating it of their own initiative, can be a factor that heightens or diminishes the risk of a management threat, depending on the source, framing and content of the request. If the request is made by someone with relevant expertise, asks for input into a broader decision and contains significant detailed information, an ORITP may be more likely to view management as willing and able to retain responsibility for and ownership of any subsequent decision. However, if the request is from someone without relevant expertise, asks for a decision or recommendation and lacks detail or alternative signs of expertise or engagement with the issue, it may be perceived as management absolving themselves of responsibility for the decision, or lacking the expertise to critically evaluate the response. Requests may lie between these indicative examples with respect to the three dimensions mentioned, and it is a matter of professional judgement whether they would be perceived as management seeking input into a decision they retain ownership over, or outsourcing the decision. |
| How directive the insight is | These factors may heighten the threat by increasing the chance that management have regard to the insight when making a decision and decreasing the chance that they critically evaluate it themselves. |
| How authoritative the insight sounds | These factors may be particularly likely to be present in relation to outputs of generative AI, which often sound highly plausible, assertive and confident. |
3.2 Self-review threat
If the insight communicated is addressed in the audit, or is reflected in the financial statements, there is the potential for a self-review threat to arise.16
Self-review threats have traditionally arisen when human auditors may be, or may be perceived to be, unable to maintain their impartiality when auditing information that reflects their own work. Where technology-enabled audit procedures are performed, a new dimension of this threat has the potential to emerge.
Where a model is used in the audit of information that has itself been informed by previous outputs of a similar or identical model, the audit procedure may be biased towards corroboration, as the model used in the generation of the insight may share knowledge, behaviours and biases with the model used to review it. This does not necessarily preclude the use of the AI model in that context, but may have implications for how it is used, supplemented and reviewed.
Where a self-review threat does arise, its significance may be enhanced if the generation of the insight involves subjective judgement, rather than the application of well-established principles and procedures, as there is then a greater degree of association between the auditor and the insight, and a correspondingly greater threat to impartiality.
Similarly, there may be a greater degree of perceived association between the auditor and the insight where it has been obtained through the use of:
- Proprietary technology of the firm. The degree of actual or perceived association between the insight and auditor may be increased further where the auditor or audit firm refers to the technology in its marketing material.
- GenAI-enabled tools that are prompted in a manner that requires judgement or encodes proprietary expertise.
The use of an engagement quality reviewer is a common safeguard against self-review threats. In this context, however, there is a potential for bias if that reviewer were to use the same or similar technology to support their review as that which was used in obtaining the insight. In these circumstances, it may be that another safeguard is appropriate, in addition or instead of the use of an engagement quality reviewer.
3.3 Self-interest threat
A self-interest threat arises when any of the firm, its partners, staff or other covered persons has financial or other interests which might cause them to be, or perceived to be, reluctant to take actions in connection with the audit that would be adverse to those interests. The Ethical Standard cites seeking to provide additional services as an example of such an interest.17
Communicating an insight can pose a self-interest threat in two main ways. The first is where a fee is received for providing the insight. The second is where no fee is received, but the communication indicates that the auditor or firm is seeking to provide services in the future that may generate a fee.
Professional judgement is required to evaluate whether the communication of an insight indicates that the auditor seeks to provide services in the future that may generate a fee. Some factors that may be relevant, but not necessarily individually determinative, are:
- The topic of the insight. An insight related to the audit or financial reporting process may be perceived as less of an indicator than an insight that relates to a topic in relation to which the firm offers advisory services.
- How the insight is communicated. Indicators may include the participation of colleagues who are not part of the audit engagement team in the presentation of the insight, and/or any mention that the firm can offer related non-audit services.
- The source of the insight. If the insight was obtained through the use of emerging or proprietary technology that the audited entity may itself lack, the threat may be heightened compared to the communication of insights derived from other sources. This is because there may be a perception that the auditor is demonstrating the capabilities of their technology as a basis for winning future work.
- The timing of the communication. If the insight is communicated at or around a time when management are due to obtain related non-audit services, it may be perceived as more of a threat than communication at another time.
3.4 Familiarity threat
If the auditor regularly communicates insights in relation to topics that are not related to the audit or financial reporting process, an ORITP may see this as a sign that they are too close to management or those charged with governance, and may therefore be insufficiently professionally sceptical of the views of the entity.
4. Ethical considerations in relation to providing an audited entity with access to technology that enables it to derive insights
This section discusses ethical considerations that may arise if the auditor were to provide audited entity personnel with access to certain technology used in the audit. If that technology can be used by audited entity personnel to derive insights about the entity or its environment, similar considerations may arise as if the auditor communicated those insights directly.
We focus on what is incrementally new or different in this scenario compared to the considerations discussed in relation to the communication of insights obtained through the use of technology.
4.1 Would provision of access constitute providing a non-audit service or a favour?
The process discussed in section 2.1, centred around determining whether provision of the service is part of the audit and, if not, whether there is an agreement to provide the service, is relevant in this context too.
The key criterion in determining whether provision of access is part of the audit is whether the purpose for providing access is to facilitate interactions that support the fulfilment of the requirements of auditing standards. This includes consideration of whether the functionality, users and duration of access are limited to supporting that purpose.
The following table includes examples to illustrate this principle.
| May be part of the audit | Less likely to be part of the audit |
|---|---|
| The auditor provides relevant audited entity personnel with temporary, limited access to a process mining tool, so that they can navigate complex process flows that cannot reasonably be represented in static form, to facilitate an informed discussion about a potential identified deficiency in internal control. | The auditor provides continuing access that enables audited entity personnel to monitor controls, identify deficiencies or generate other insights for their own purposes. |
| The auditor provides the audit committee with access to an interactive dashboard showing static data underlying a key auditor conclusion. | The auditor provides management with access to a visualisation tool that allows them to create new dashboards of their data at will. |
| The auditor provides management with access to a limited interface within a risk scoring tool so that it can inspect a sample of flagged transactions and provide explanations. | The auditor provides access to a risk scoring tool that includes the ability to inspect scores of the whole population and run the tool again with different data or parameters. |
4.2 Would provision of access pose a threat to integrity, objectivity or independence?
Many of the considerations discussed in section 3 are relevant to assessing whether providing access to technology may pose threats to integrity, objectivity or independence. The following subsections discuss considerations that are new or different in this context.
4.2.1 Management threat
If it is probable that an ORITP would conclude that providing access to the relevant technology, which may or may not be a non-audit service, would constitute playing the role of management, or playing any part in management decision making, then it is prohibited.
As with the communication of insights, discussed in section 3.1, providing access to technology could have implications for the perception of the auditor's role relating to the internal controls of the audited entity, and relating to management decisions if management use the technology to obtain significant insights or insights they do not appropriately critically evaluate.
Many of the factors discussed in section 3.1 as potentially relevant to an assessment of management threat are again relevant in this context, and the table below discusses some that may be additionally relevant.
| Factor | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Length of time access is available Reusability of the technology The control environment at the entity |
These may be relevant to an ORITP view of whether the auditor would be in substance designing, implementing and maintaining an internal control. For example, access that is granted for longer than the time relevant to facilitate specific audit work; management ability to upload new data to reuse the technology; or known weaknesses in the control environment could all be perceived as enhancing the management threat. Reusability of the technology The control environment at the entity |
| Extent to which the technology itself performs analysis | The extent to which the technology itself performs analysis and generates evaluative outputs, rather than providing tools through which management perform their own analysis, may be relevant to an evaluation of management threat. Technology that is at the former end of this spectrum may carry a heightened risk that an ORITP would perceive auditor technology as in substance playing a part in management decision making. For example, access to auditor-provided technology that is used solely to visualise data in dashboards whose design reflects management judgement about how the data should be presented may not represent a management threat, but access to auditor-provided technology that uses proprietary algorithms to risk score transactions may create a heightened management threat. |
4.2.2 Self-review threat
Section 3.2 discusses the self-review threat: the risk that auditors may be, or may be perceived to be, unable to maintain impartiality when auditing information that reflects their own work, including the risk that technology-enabled audit procedures could be biased towards corroborating information informed by outputs of similar or identical technology.
Self-review threats may also arise where information addressed in the audit reflects analysis performed by auditor-provided technology, with many of the same considerations relevant.
The degree of perceived association between the auditor and the resulting information may depend on the extent to which the auditor-provided technology itself performs the analysis and generates evaluative outputs, rather than providing tools through which management perform their own analysis and apply their own judgement.
Where management use the technology to arrive at a figure or operate a control, and the auditor uses the same technology to audit that figure or control, there may be correlated errors and biases. The audit procedure may reproduce errors or corroborate judgements arising from management's use of the technology, without providing independent challenge.
The auditor should also consider the specific prohibition in paragraph 5.52 of the Ethical Standard on designing, providing or implementing information technology systems that are important to a significant part of the accounting or financial management system, or to the production of the financial statements, if the auditor would place significant reliance on them in the audit.
4.2.3 Self-interest threat
The considerations discussed in section 3.3 may be relevant when evaluating whether providing access to technology creates a self-interest threat, including where a fee is received for access or where providing access may be perceived as demonstrating the technology's capabilities to obtain future fee-generating work.
Particular consideration may be given to whether the firm has a financial interest in management's continued use of the technology, for example through licensing, renewal or related support fees.
4.2.4 Familiarity threat
If the auditor provides access to technology for reasons other than facilitating audit work, an ORITP may see this as a sign that they are too close to management or those charged with governance, and may therefore be insufficiently professionally sceptical of the views of the entity.
5. Illustrative examples
These illustrative examples portray the considerations and conclusions of a firm in hypothetical and simplified scenarios. They lack much of the relevant information that would be available in real-life scenarios, and so caution is required when considering their relevance to apparently similar scenarios.
Illustrative example 1
Background
A firm is appointed as auditor of a public interest entity. During the audit tender process, the firm discusses its intention to deploy an AI-enabled tool in its audit work over revenue recognition. It is also discussed that use of the tool may generate customer-related insights that could be of interest to management, with a shared understanding that the firm would communicate such insights if they arose.
No separate engagement letter is signed for this potential service, and no separate fee is agreed.
Work performed
The audit team deploys an AI-enabled tool, designed to analyse customer contracts, invoices, credit notes and revenue transactions, in order to provide audit evidence about whether invoiced and recorded amounts are consistent with contractual pricing, discounts and other relevant terms.
The audit team runs this tool for the purpose of providing evidence to support the audit opinion, but subsequently chooses to perform alternative procedures in relation to revenue recognition. They therefore do not complete the AI-enabled procedure, and do not consider the output when forming their audit opinion.
The audit team later performs a limited amount of separate work, analysing the same output of the AI-enabled tool, in order to generate customer-related insights that may be of interest to management. This analysis compares the discounts received by customers with similar purchasing characteristics. It identifies groups of customers receiving materially higher discounts without corresponding differences in purchasing volume, and calculates the difference between the revenue recorded and the revenue that would have been recorded had consistent discount rates been applied.
The auditor considers whether the information obtained through the additional analysis has implications for the audit, including for the assessment of risks of material misstatement due to fraud, and whether further audit procedures are necessary.
Is the communication required by the auditing standards?
The auditor determines that communicating the additional analysis is not required by the auditing standards.
Would communicating the insight constitute providing a non-audit service or a favour?
The auditor considers whether the work forms part of the audit. The initial analysis of revenue transactions and contractual terms was designed and performed to support the audit opinion, and therefore forms part of the audit. The purpose for which the work was performed is not altered by the audit team's subsequent decision not to use the output to support the audit opinion.
By contrast, the additional comparison of customer discounts was not performed to support the audit opinion. The auditor therefore concludes that the marginal additional work, and the communication of the resulting insight, are not part of the audit.
Although no separate engagement letter or fee was agreed, the prospect of generating and communicating customer insights was discussed during the audit tender process. The auditor judges that the discussion amounted to a tacit agreement to provide such insights and, therefore, that communication would constitute providing an engagement and therefore a non-audit service.
Because no fee is charged in relation to the non-audit service, the auditor considers that performing the additional work constitutes a favour.
Would threats to integrity, objectivity or independence arise?
The auditor assesses the threats that could arise from communicating the insights arising from the additional work. The perspective of an objective, reasonable and informed third party is central to that assessment.
Management threat
The auditor concludes that communicating the insights would not constitute playing a management role or participating in management decision-making. In reaching this conclusion, they consider that:
- management has the expertise necessary to understand the analysis, assess whether the identified customer groups are genuinely comparable, evaluate whether the differences in discounts are commercially justified and determine whether any action should be taken;
- the criteria by which customers have been categorised and compared are transparent and capable of being evaluated by management, and management can confirm the accuracy of the identified discount information, so the opacity of the technology does not limit the ability of management to critically evaluate the insight;
- the analysis is a discrete exercise, rather than a recurring service on which management may become reliant;
- the analysis is presented in neutral, fact-based language and does not characterise particular discounts as excessive, inappropriate or commercially suboptimal; and
- the firm communicates the identified patterns and estimated effect on revenue, but does not recommend changes to customer pricing or discounts.
Self-review threat
Although the additional analysis may have implications for the current or subsequent audits, the auditor concludes that communicating the insight is not expected to give rise to a self-review threat.
In reaching this conclusion, the auditor considers that the additional analysis identifies patterns of potential significance rather than reaching conclusions. They judge that investigating audit implications would not ordinarily put them in the position of evaluating conclusions they had themselves provided.
The auditor also considers that management changing its pricing in response to the observation would not, in itself, create a self-review threat in a subsequent audit. They expect to assess whether revenue from the resulting contracts and transactions is appropriately accounted for, rather than whether the earlier analysis was correct or the pricing changes commercially justified. They do not expect management to incorporate the additional analysis into accounting judgements, amounts or controls that would subsequently be subject to audit.
Self-interest threat
No fee is charged for the additional work. However, the auditor considers whether communicating a commercially valuable insight could create a perception that it is demonstrating its technological capabilities in order to sell additional services.
The analysis is performed and communicated solely by members of the audit team, and the communication does not suggest that the firm could perform further work relating to pricing or profitability. The auditor therefore concludes that the communication does not indicate that the firm is seeking to provide additional services.
Familiarity threat
The auditor also considers whether providing the insight could indicate an unduly close relationship with management. They conclude that the limited, non-recurring nature of the work does not give rise to a familiarity threat that would compromise independence.
Is communication of the insight permitted?
The non-audit service concerns information of the audited entity, and the understanding of the entity obtained by the auditor is relevant to the service. The auditor has concluded that the service would not compromise independence, from either a threat-based or provision of favours perspective.
Therefore, it is a permitted non-audit service under paragraph 5.40, subject to the approval of the audit committee.
The auditor discusses the proposed service and its assessment of the related threats with the audit committee and obtains the audit committee's approval before communicating the insight to management.
No fee is charged and, therefore, the non-audit services fee cap is not a relevant consideration.
The auditor judges that an ORITP would perceive the marginal additional work to be trivial and conclude that the favour provisions of the Ethical Standard would not prohibit communication.
The auditor communicates the insight to management.
Subsequent actions
The auditor:
- communicates the provision of the non-audit service to the audit committee in accordance with paragraph 1.62(b) of the Ethical Standard;
- communicates relevant information about the service to appropriate parties within the firm;
- documents their significant judgements and conclusions, including:
- why the initial work formed part of the audit but the marginal additional work constituted a non-audit service;
- their assessment of the threats to integrity, objectivity and independence, including that there is informed management in accordance with paragraph 5.34 of the Ethical Standard;
- the triviality of the additional work in the context of the provision of favours; and
- why the service was permissible under paragraph 5.40 of the Ethical Standard; and
- considers whether the non-audit service has been disclosed in the annual report and whether disclosure in the auditor's report is required.
Illustrative example 2
Background
A firm is appointed as auditor of an entity.
Work performed
The audit team performs data analytics as part of their audit of expenses, to obtain evidence to support the audit opinion. The analysis identifies that expenditure in certain areas has increased, and that this spending has grown concentrated in a relatively low number of suppliers.
Is the communication required by the auditing standards?
The auditor judges that communicating the observation to management is not required by the auditing standards.
Would communicating the insight constitute providing a non-audit service or a favour?
The work was performed to support the audit opinion, with its nature and extent determined by the auditor and its principal terms and conditions the same as those of the audit. The auditor knows that this means that communicating the resulting observation would not constitute providing a non-audit service or a favour.
Would threats to integrity, objectivity or independence arise?
The auditor has a general awareness of the circumstances in which communicating insights may pose threats, but nothing in this scenario suggests to them that such circumstances are present. Therefore, the auditor does not perform a formal consideration of the potential threats.
Is communication of the insight permitted?
The auditor considers communication permissible and communicates the observation to management.
Subsequent actions
The auditor documents the work performed and the evidence obtained to support the audit opinion. The auditor does not separately document the ethical considerations relating to the observation or its communication to management.
Financial Reporting Council
London office:
13th Floor, 1 Harbour Exchange Square, London, E14 9GE
Birmingham office:
5th Floor, 3 Arena Central, Bridge Street, Birmingham, B1 2AX
+44 (0)20 7492 2300
Follow us on LinkedIn
Footnotes
-
International Standard on Auditing (UK) 260 (Revised November 2019) 'Communication With Those Charged With Governance' ↩
-
International Standard on Auditing (UK) 265 'Communicating Deficiencies in Internal Control to Those Charged With Governance and Management' ↩
-
International Standard on Auditing (UK) 240 (Revised May 2021) 'The Auditor's Responsibilities Relating to Fraud in an Audit of Financial Statements', 41-43 ↩
-
International Standard on Auditing (UK) 250 (Revised November 2019) Section A — 'Consideration of Laws and Regulations in an Audit of Financial Statements', 20; 23-25 ↩
-
International Standard on Auditing (UK) 450 (Revised June 2016) 'Evaluation of Misstatements Identified During the Audit', 8; 12–13 ↩
-
International Standard on Auditing (UK) 550 'Related Parties', 27 ↩
-
International Standard on Auditing (UK) 570 (Revised September 2019) 'Going Concern', 25 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 5.7 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 5.4 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 4.38 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 5.40 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 1.33 ↩
-
FRC Guidance – The Objective, Reasonable and Informed Third Party Test, 2024 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 1.33 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 1.28 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 1.33 ↩
-
FRC Ethical Standard 2024, 1.33 ↩